Basic Percentage Play
It is surprisingly rare that an in-depth knowledge of probabilities is key to landing a contract (relief!). Even if you do know that the à priori chances of (say) a 4-1 split are 28%, those odds will probably be different when you come to broach the suit: the bidding and play to date will have altered those odds. All you really need to know about odds in practical play is:
A missing odd number of cards rate to split as evenly as possible (eg five missing cards rates to split 3-2). Therefore a finesse (50-50) is less likely than the most even split.
A missing even number of cards does not rate to split evenly (eg four missing cards do not rate to split 2-2 [this is because a 3-1 (or the less likely 4-0) split can occur in two ways: three of the left – one on the right; or one on the left – three on the right]). Therefore a finesse is more likely than the even split.
Which of these suits is most likely to generate an extra trick? Least likely?
(i) |
♦ A Q 3 2 |
(ii) |
♣ A Q 3 2 |
(iii) |
♥ A Q |
|
--- |
|
--- |
|
--- |
|
♦ K 5 4 |
|
♣ K 6 5 4 |
|
♥ 3 2 |
However in practical play, a comparison of these odds is not normally necessary.
Say you are wide-open in spades and need one extra trick from the other three suits (as above). You would cash ♣ AKQ and ♦ AKQ in some order, finishing with a king. If either clubs have split 3-2 (quite likely – 68% if you’re curious) or diamonds have split 3-3 (quite unlikely – 36%), you have a long card. If neither cooperate, then the last resort is to lead to ♥ Q.
South Deals
None Vul |
♠ |
J 9 6 |
♥ |
A K 3 |
♦ |
7 5 3 2 |
♣ |
9 5 2 |
|
♠ |
A Q 7 2 |
♥ |
10 5 |
♦ |
10 8 4 |
♣ |
K 10 8 4 |
|
|
|
|
|
♠ |
K 10 8 3 |
♥ |
9 8 6 2 |
♦ |
J 9 |
♣ |
J 7 3 |
|
|
|
♠ |
5 4 |
♥ |
Q J 7 4 |
♦ |
A K Q 6 |
♣ |
A Q 6 |
|
West |
North |
East |
South |
|
|
|
1 ♥ |
Pass |
2 ♥1 |
Pass |
2 NT2 |
Pass |
3 N3 |
Pass |
Pass |
Pass |
|
|
|
-
Better than 1 NT with three decent hearts.
-
Suggesting notrumps, in case partner has raised with three. 2 NT shows about 17-18.
-
Near-maximum point-count
|
Sometimes, however, you might be put to a premature guess – as on our deal. The defence took their four spades, East winning the fourth and switching to a club.
Declarer, who had thrown a club from dummy and a club and a diamond from hand, had eight top tricks. He had to decide whether to finesse the queen of clubs for his ninth; or rely on a 3-2 diamond split and a fourth trick in that suit.
The 3-2 diamond split being better odds, he rose with the ace of clubs, cashed the three top diamonds (good – 3-2 split revealed), over to a top heart, cashed the long diamond throwing the queen of clubs and finished with his three remaining top hearts. Nine tricks and game made.